Skip to content

Compare activity rules along a composition path

Download Python script

Python · section 1
"""Explore mixing rules and activity calculations.
This example walks through mass-based, molar-based, and volume-based
mixing rules, compares ideal activities, and demonstrates the
kappa value parameterization to model non-ideal solution behavior. Each
section builds the required data arrays, computes activities with the
public ``par.particles`` helpers, and plots the results.
Example:
Run this example to generate activity plots for two- and
three-component systems under different mixing assumptions.
"""
'Explore mixing rules and activity calculations.\n\nThis example walks through mass-based, molar-based, and volume-based\nmixing rules, compares ideal activities, and demonstrates the\nkappa value parameterization to model non-ideal solution behavior. Each\nsection builds the required data arrays, computes activities with the\npublic ``par.particles`` helpers, and plots the results.\n\nExample:\n    Run this example to generate activity plots for two- and\nthree-component systems under different mixing assumptions.\n'

Compare activity rules along a composition path

Section titled “Compare activity rules along a composition path”

How much can an assumed mixing rule change the activity assigned to the same mixture? We follow binary and ternary composition paths, comparing mole-, volume-, and mass-fraction rules with a κ water-activity parameterization. This helps separate a change of composition coordinates from a change of thermodynamic model before coupling activity to condensation.

Every vertical axis is activity, not activity coefficient. In the molar standard-state convention, ; ideal molar mixing has but generally . Substituting mass or volume fraction for activity is a different approximation, not another way to plot the same Raoult-law prediction. These generic components are not a calibrated material system. For construction interfaces, continue with the strategy comparison.

Python · section 2
# In Colab uncomment the following command to install particula:
# Install from the repository root: `python -m pip install -e ".[extra]"`
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
import numpy as np
import particula as par

Define the path before interpreting the curves

Section titled “Define the path before interpreting the curves”

Water mass increases from 0 to 100 relative units while component 2 remains at 30. In the ternary path, component 3 decreases from 150 to 10. The common mass scale cancels in these rules; total mass is not held constant. Densities are kg/m³ and molar masses are kg/mol.

All panels use water mole fraction on the horizontal axis, computed once from these same masses. The ternary curves therefore trace one changing composition path, not a full ternary phase diagram. Component 3’s relative abundance changes at the same time as water’s.

Python · section 3
masses_1 = np.linspace(0, 100, 1000)
masses_2 = np.full_like(masses_1, 30)
masses_3 = np.linspace(150, 10, 1000)
density_1 = 1000 # kg/m^3
density_2 = 2000 # kg/m^3
density_3 = 1500 # kg/m^3
molar_mass_1 = 18.01528e-3 # kg/mol
molar_mass_2 = 200e-3 # kg/mol
molar_mass_3 = 150e-3 # kg/mol
mass_2component = np.column_stack((masses_1, masses_2))
mass_3component = np.column_stack((masses_1, masses_2, masses_3))
density_2component = np.array([density_1, density_2])
density_3component = np.array([density_1, density_2, density_3])
# get mole fractions
mole_fractions_2component = par.particles.get_mole_fraction_from_mass(
mass_2component, molar_masses=np.array([molar_mass_1, molar_mass_2])
)
mole_fractions_3component = par.particles.get_mole_fraction_from_mass(
mass_3component,
molar_masses=np.array([molar_mass_1, molar_mass_2, molar_mass_3]),
)

Ideal molar activity equals mole fraction. Water’s curve therefore lies on in both panels. In the binary panel, the solute follows ; in the ternary panel, the two solutes share that remainder according to the chosen path. This is a reference model, not evidence that the generic mixture is ideal.

Python · section 4
activity_2component_molar = par.particles.get_ideal_activity_molar(
mass_concentration=mass_2component,
molar_mass=np.array([molar_mass_1, molar_mass_2]),
)
activity_3component_molar = par.particles.get_ideal_activity_molar(
mass_concentration=mass_3component,
molar_mass=np.array([molar_mass_1, molar_mass_2, molar_mass_3]),
)
# Create the figure and axis objects
fig, ax = plt.subplots(2, 1, figsize=(5, 8))
# Plot each component in the 2-component system with separate colors
ax[0].plot(
mole_fractions_2component[:, 0],
activity_2component_molar[:, 0],
color="blue",
label="Water (1)",
)
ax[0].plot(
mole_fractions_2component[:, 0],
activity_2component_molar[:, 1],
color="green",
label="Component 2",
)
ax[0].set_xlabel("Water Mole Fraction")
ax[0].set_ylabel("Activity")
ax[0].set_title("Binary molar-based activity")
ax[0].legend()
# Plot the 3-component system without setting specific colors
ax[1].plot(
mole_fractions_3component[:, 0],
activity_3component_molar[:, 0],
label="Water (1)",
color="blue",
)
ax[1].plot(
mole_fractions_3component[:, 0],
activity_3component_molar[:, 1],
label="Component 2",
color="green",
)
ax[1].plot(
mole_fractions_3component[:, 0],
activity_3component_molar[:, 2],
label="Component 3",
color="red",
)
ax[1].set_xlabel("Water Mole Fraction")
ax[1].set_ylabel("Activity")
ax[1].set_title("Ternary molar-based activity")
ax[1].legend()
# Display the plot
plt.tight_layout()
plt.show()
Compare activity rules along a composition path: saved scientific figure
Compare activity rules along a composition path · saved execution output

The volume rule normalizes and returns those fractions as activities. Its curves need not lie on the molar reference, even though the horizontal coordinate is unchanged. The assumed additive component volumes and the choice to equate volume fraction with activity are separate modeling assumptions; density conversion alone does not establish thermodynamic accuracy.

Python · section 5
# Volume activity
activity_2component_volume = par.particles.get_ideal_activity_volume(
mass_concentration=mass_2component,
density=density_2component,
)
activity_3component_volume = par.particles.get_ideal_activity_volume(
mass_concentration=mass_3component,
density=density_3component,
)
# Create the figure and axis objects
fig, ax = plt.subplots(2, 1, figsize=(5, 8))
# Plot each component in the 2-component system with separate colors
ax[0].plot(
mole_fractions_2component[:, 0],
activity_2component_volume[:, 0],
color="blue",
label="Water (1)",
)
ax[0].plot(
mole_fractions_2component[:, 0],
activity_2component_volume[:, 1],
color="green",
label="Component 2",
)
ax[0].set_xlabel("Water Mole Fraction")
ax[0].set_ylabel("Activity")
ax[0].set_title("Binary volume-based activity")
ax[0].legend()
# Plot the 3-component system without setting specific colors
ax[1].plot(
mole_fractions_3component[:, 0],
activity_3component_volume[:, 0],
label="Water (1)",
color="blue",
)
ax[1].plot(
mole_fractions_3component[:, 0],
activity_3component_volume[:, 1],
label="Component 2",
color="green",
)
ax[1].plot(
mole_fractions_3component[:, 0],
activity_3component_volume[:, 2],
label="Component 3",
color="red",
)
ax[1].set_xlabel("Water Mole Fraction")
ax[1].set_ylabel("Activity")
ax[1].set_title("Ternary volume-based activity")
ax[1].legend()
# Display the plot
plt.tight_layout()
plt.show()
Compare activity rules along a composition path: saved scientific figure
Compare activity rules along a composition path · saved execution output

The mass rule normalizes the input masses directly. Because water is much lighter per molecule than either solute, its mass fraction is below its mole fraction along these paths. The curved water trace against is therefore expected. It does not indicate a numerically inconsistent mass conversion.

Python · section 6
# Mass activity
activity_2component_mass = par.particles.get_ideal_activity_mass(
mass_concentration=mass_2component,
)
activity_3component_mass = par.particles.get_ideal_activity_mass(
mass_concentration=mass_3component,
)
# Create the figure and axis objects
fig, ax = plt.subplots(2, 1, figsize=(5, 8))
# Plot each component in the 2-component system with separate colors
ax[0].plot(
mole_fractions_2component[:, 0],
activity_2component_mass[:, 0],
color="blue",
label="Water (1)",
linewidth=4,
linestyle="--",
)
ax[0].plot(
mole_fractions_2component[:, 0],
activity_2component_mass[:, 1],
color="green",
label="Component 2",
)
ax[0].set_xlabel("Water Mole Fraction")
ax[0].set_ylabel("Activity")
ax[0].set_title("Binary mass-based activity")
ax[0].legend()
# Plot the 3-component system without setting specific colors
ax[1].plot(
mole_fractions_3component[:, 0],
activity_3component_mass[:, 0],
label="Water (1)",
color="blue",
linewidth=4,
linestyle="--",
)
ax[1].plot(
mole_fractions_3component[:, 0],
activity_3component_mass[:, 1],
label="Component 2",
color="green",
linewidth=3,
)
ax[1].plot(
mole_fractions_3component[:, 0],
activity_3component_mass[:, 2],
label="Component 3",
color="red",
)
ax[1].set_xlabel("Water Mole Fraction")
ax[1].set_ylabel("Activity")
ax[1].set_title("Ternary mass-based activity")
ax[1].legend()
# Display the plot
plt.tight_layout()
plt.show()
Compare activity rules along a composition path: saved scientific figure
Compare activity rules along a composition path · saved execution output

The illustrative solutes have κ=0.6 and 1.2; the water lane’s κ is unused. Water activity follows for the solute volumes . Its dry endpoint is zero here. Along the ternary path, the relative contributions of the two solutes also change, so there is no single constant effective solute κ for the entire curve.

The nonwater lanes retain ideal molar activities. Compare them with the first pair of panels to see that this model changes water’s rule without computing nonideal activity coefficients for every component. The parameterization follows Petters and Kreidenweis (2007); the particular solute parameters here are illustrative.

Python · section 7
# kappa activity
kappa_1 = 0.0 # kappa of water
kappa_2 = 0.6 # kappa of component 2
kappa_3 = 1.2 # kappa of component 3
water_index = 0
activity_2component_kappa = par.particles.get_kappa_activity(
mass_concentration=mass_2component,
kappa=np.array([kappa_1, kappa_2]),
density=density_2component,
molar_mass=np.array([molar_mass_1, molar_mass_2]),
water_index=water_index,
)
activity_3component_kappa = par.particles.get_kappa_activity(
mass_concentration=mass_3component,
kappa=np.array([kappa_1, kappa_2, kappa_3]),
density=density_3component,
molar_mass=np.array([molar_mass_1, molar_mass_2, molar_mass_3]),
water_index=water_index,
)
# Create the figure and axis objects
fig, ax = plt.subplots(2, 1, figsize=(5, 8))
# Plot each component in the 2-component system with separate colors
ax[0].plot(
mole_fractions_2component[:, 0],
activity_2component_kappa[:, 0],
color="blue",
label="Water (1)",
)
ax[0].plot(
mole_fractions_2component[:, 0],
activity_2component_kappa[:, 1],
color="green",
label="Component 2",
)
ax[0].set_xlabel("Water Mole Fraction")
ax[0].set_ylabel("Activity")
ax[0].set_title("Binary κ activity")
ax[0].legend()
# Plot the 3-component system without setting specific colors
ax[1].plot(
mole_fractions_3component[:, 0],
activity_3component_kappa[:, 0],
label="Water (1)",
color="blue",
)
ax[1].plot(
mole_fractions_3component[:, 0],
activity_3component_kappa[:, 1],
label="Component 2",
color="green",
)
ax[1].plot(
mole_fractions_3component[:, 0],
activity_3component_kappa[:, 2],
label="Component 3",
color="red",
)
ax[1].set_xlabel("Water Mole Fraction")
ax[1].set_ylabel("Activity")
ax[1].set_title("Ternary κ activity")
ax[1].legend()
# Display the plot
plt.tight_layout()
plt.show()
Compare activity rules along a composition path: saved scientific figure
Compare activity rules along a composition path · saved execution output

The composition path and its mole-fraction coordinate stay fixed, while the predicted activities change. Thus interpreting a condensation calculation requires naming its activity approximation as well as its composition. Agreement at an endpoint or the fact that fractions sum to one does not choose the physically appropriate rule.

For a research comparison, hold the dry solute ratio fixed, vary only water, and compare predicted with measured water activity at one temperature. Use residuals over the measured range to assess a fitted κ against ideal molar mixing. That controlled path would separate water uptake from the changing dry composition used in the ternary illustration here.

Explore this topic: Chemical activity