Skip to content

Which composition rule controls equilibrium pressure?

Download Python script

Python · section 1
"""Activity tutorial for mixing rules and water activity predictions.
This tutorial demonstrates mixing behavior in aerosol solutions, including
ideal and non-ideal mixing rules. Topics covered include mass-based and
molar-based activity calculations, and kappa value parameterization for
predicting water activity in non-ideal solutions.
Example:
Run this tutorial to learn about different activity strategies::
import particula as par
activity_mass = par.particles.ActivityIdealMass()
activities = activity_mass.activity(mass_concentration=[0.2, 0.8])
"""
# ---
# jupyter:
# jupytext:
# text_representation:
# extension: .py
# format_name: percent
# format_version: '1.3'
# jupytext_version: 1.17.3
# kernelspec:
# display_name: .venv
# language: python
# name: python3
# ---
'Activity tutorial for mixing rules and water activity predictions.\n\nThis tutorial demonstrates mixing behavior in aerosol solutions, including\nideal and non-ideal mixing rules. Topics covered include mass-based and\nmolar-based activity calculations, and kappa value parameterization for\npredicting water activity in non-ideal solutions.\n\nExample:\n    Run this tutorial to learn about different activity strategies::\n\n        import particula as par\n        activity_mass = par.particles.ActivityIdealMass()\n        activities = activity_mass.activity(mass_concentration=[0.2, 0.8])\n'

Which composition rule controls equilibrium pressure?

Section titled “Which composition rule controls equilibrium pressure?”

A mixture containing 20% water by mass need not have water activity 0.2. Molecules, mass, and liquid volume weight the same composition differently. Here we compare three activity approximations for water and a sucrose-like solute, then see how each changes the flat-interface pressure .

The calculation separates two choices: the physical activity rule and the construction interface (direct strategy, builder, or factory). Switching an interface does not itself change the physics. Read the activity functions for a wider composition comparison; curvature is an additional effect omitted here.

Python · section 2
# In Colab uncomment the following command to install particula:
# Install from the repository root: `python -m pip install -e ".[extra]"`
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
import numpy as np
import particula as par

ActivityIdealMass sets each activity equal to its mass fraction. This is a mass-based approximation, distinct from the usual mole-fraction Raoult law. The [water, solute] mass ratio is [0.2, 0.8]; its common absolute scale cancels. The pressures [100, 10] Pa are deliberately illustrative, not measured water and sucrose vapor pressures. The returned [20, 8] Pa simply exposes the multiplication by activity.

Python · section 3
activity_mass = par.particles.ActivityIdealMass() # no parameters needed
# mixture
mass_mixture = np.array([0.2, 0.8]) # water, sucrose
activities = activity_mass.activity(mass_concentration=mass_mixture)
print(f"Activities: {activities}")
# partial pressures
pure_pressure = np.array([100, 10]) # water, sucrose
partial_pressures = activity_mass.partial_pressure(
pure_vapor_pressure=pure_pressure, mass_concentration=mass_mixture
)
print(f"Partial pressures: {partial_pressures}")
Activities: [0.2 0.8]
Partial pressures: [20.  8.]

The builder takes molar masses in kg/mol. Water’s smaller molar mass means that 20% of the mixture’s mass represents most of its molecules. Consequently the ideal molar water activity exceeds the mass-based value, while the solute activity is smaller. The pressure change follows from this different model; it is not caused by using a builder instead of direct construction.

Python · section 4
activity_molar = (
par.particles.ActivityIdealMolarBuilder()
.set_molar_mass(
np.array([18.01528, 342.29648]) * 1e-3, "kg/mol"
) # water, sucrose
.build()
)
# mixture
activities = activity_molar.activity(mass_concentration=mass_mixture)
print(f"Activities: {activities}")
# partial pressures
pure_pressure = np.array([100, 10]) # water, sucrose
partial_pressures = activity_molar.partial_pressure(
pure_vapor_pressure=pure_pressure, mass_concentration=mass_mixture
)
print(f"Partial pressures: {partial_pressures}")
Activities: [0.82608954 0.17391046]
Partial pressures: [82.6089542   1.73910458]

The factory converts the supplied g/mol values and applies the κ water-activity rule using species densities in kg/m³. The solute κ=0.3 and density 1500 kg/m³ are illustrative choices, not a fitted sucrose property set. Water occupies lane zero. Nonwater activities retain the ideal molar rule, so this is not a complete nonideal model for every species.

Python · section 5
parameters_input = {
"density": np.array(
[1000, 1500]
), # water, sucrose, kg/m^3 are the base SI default units
"density_units": "kg/m^3", # this tells the factory what the input units are so it can convert to kg/m^3
"molar_mass": np.array([18.01528, 342.29648]), # water, sucrose
"molar_mass_units": "g/mol", # this tells the factory what the input units are so it can convert to kg/mol
"kappa": np.array([0, 0.3]), # water, sucrose
"water_index": 0, # water is the first component
}
activity_kappa = par.particles.ActivityFactory().get_strategy(
strategy_type="kappa", parameters=parameters_input
)
# mixture
activities = activity_kappa.activity(mass_concentration=mass_mixture)
print(f"Activities: {activities}")
# partial pressures
pure_pressure = np.array([100, 10]) # water, sucrose
partial_pressures = activity_kappa.partial_pressure(
pure_vapor_pressure=pure_pressure, mass_concentration=mass_mixture
)
print(f"Partial pressures: {partial_pressures}")
Activities: [0.55555556 0.17391046]
Partial pressures: [55.55555556  1.73910458]

Increase water mass fraction while keeping total relative mass equal to one. The solid curves compare water activity under the three assumptions. The dashed κ solute curve coincides with the molar solute curve by construction. Only activities are plotted; the preceding pressure calculations explain how these curves would scale a chosen pure-component vapor pressure.

A separation between curves measures model sensitivity, not which model is accurate. An experimental water-activity relation at the relevant temperature and composition would be needed to decide that.

Python · section 6
mass_water = np.linspace(0.001, 0.9999, 100)
mass_sucrose = 1 - mass_water
mass_mixture = np.array([mass_water, mass_sucrose]).T
activities_mass = np.zeros_like(mass_mixture)
activities_molar = np.zeros_like(mass_mixture)
activities_kappa = np.zeros_like(mass_mixture)
for i, mass in enumerate(mass_mixture):
activities_mass[i] = activity_mass.activity(mass_concentration=mass)
activities_molar[i] = activity_molar.activity(mass_concentration=mass)
activities_kappa[i] = activity_kappa.activity(mass_concentration=mass)
fig, ax = plt.subplots(figsize=(8, 6))
ax.plot(mass_water, activities_mass[:, 0], label="Mass: Water")
ax.plot(
mass_water, activities_mass[:, 1], label="Mass: Sucrose", linestyle="--"
)
ax.plot(mass_water, activities_molar[:, 0], label="Molar: Water")
ax.plot(
mass_water,
activities_molar[:, 1],
label="Molar: Sucrose",
linestyle="--",
linewidth=3,
alpha=0.85,
)
ax.plot(mass_water, activities_kappa[:, 0], label="Kappa: Water")
ax.plot(
mass_water, activities_kappa[:, 1], label="Kappa: Sucrose", linestyle="--"
)
ax.set_xlabel("Mass fraction water")
ax.set_ylabel("Activity")
ax.legend()
plt.show()
Which composition rule controls equilibrium pressure?: saved scientific figure
Which composition rule controls equilibrium pressure? · saved execution output

Turn a model choice into a testable question

Section titled “Turn a model choice into a testable question”

Composition alone does not determine the pressure reduction until an activity rule is specified. For a light solvent and heavy solute, replacing mass fraction with mole fraction can substantially change that reduction. κ adds a separate water-uptake assumption while leaving the nonwater molar rule intact.

As a useful interface check, construct the same molar model directly, through a builder, and through the factory, then compare activities on this grid. For a scientific extension, fit κ to measured water activity and compare residuals against ideal molar predictions over the measured range. Neither exercise is performed here; fitted behavior outside that range would need new evidence.

Explore this topic: Chemical activity